Pantnagar Startup Incubation and Entrepreneurship Development Society (Pant STRIEDS)
G. B. Pant University of Agriculture and Technology, Pantnagar

The following evaluation matrix is utilized for evaluating the Start-up ideas received from students/entrepreneurs looking for recognition at Startup Uttarakhand or getting incubated at Pant STRIEDS.

EVALUATION MATRIX

1. General Parameters

Sl.No.Evaluation ParametersWeightage CriteriaMax WeightageScore Awarded
1.Start-up Incorporated asPrivate ltd - 10,
Partnership -7,
Limited liability Partnership -10
10
2.Start-up Incorporated atUttarakhand – 10
Outside Uttarakhand -8
10
3.Start-up in Business< 2 years - 5,
2 to 4 years- 10,
4 to7 years -7
10
4.Business IdeaCollective marking on various parameters listed below Clarity of thought – 5
MVP ready – 5 Revenue above 1 lakh – 10
Repeat/referral customer - 10
15
5.Business SectorTour & Travel -15
Food Procesing-10 AYUSH-15
Education-10 Healthcare-15
Biotechnology-15IT/ITES-10
Energy-15
Skill development-10
Agriculture-15
Herbal and Organic Products-15
15
6.Team ConstitutionCollective marking on various parameters listed below Past experience in the field – 5
No. of founders Single Founder- 5 Duo Founder-7 Tri Founder-6
10
7.Scalability of the business modelYes (With description of process) – 20
Yes (without description)-15
20
8.Potential of employment generationUpto 10 person –5
Upto 20 person –7
Upto 30 person-10
10
Total:100


2. Technical Parameters

Sl.No.Evaluation ParametersWeightage CriteriaMax WeightageScore Awarded
1.Problem StatementIs the problem clearly defined ?5
2.Proposed SolutionWhat is the proposed solution ?
Does it completely solve the defined problem?
What is the Product/Services - brief description of core technology/solution
Are there any close alternatives available in the market ?
15
3.Product / ServicesDoes this Product/Service solve any technical issues in the existing products/services through the use of Technology
How easy it is to replicate the proposed product/service by competitor
10
4.InnovativenessIs there any innovative element / differentiating factor in the Product/service ?
Is the product/process patentable
10
5.Complexity of SolutionHow complex the proposed solution is ?
Can it completely replace the existing product/services?
10
6.Market ReadinessIs the working prototype ready ?
Does it Need further improvement ?
Is the data of product/service testing or user trails available to back the claim
Is the product/service ready for the Pilot Project
15
7.PricingHow competitive is the pricing of the product/services
What is the costing of the Product/services vis-à-vis price of alternative products>
Is there any scope for improving in the pricing strategy
10
8.Team Technical Expertise and BackgroundBackground of Team Members
Technical Knowledge & Domain Expertise of Team Members
Understanding about the Industry
10
9.Market Size- Regional Level
- National Level
- International Level
5
10.Key Competitors5
11.Market Segmentation & defining target market5
Total:100


Final Score Card for Evaluating Startups

1. General Parameters

Sl.No.Evaluation ParametersMarks Obtained
1.Start-up Incorporated as
2.Start-up Incorporated at
3.Start-up in Business
4.Business Idea
5.Business Sector
6.Team Constitution
7.Scalability of the business model
8.Potential of employment generation
Total:


2. Technical Parameters

Sl.No.Evaluation ParametersMarks Obtained
1.Problem Statement
2.Proposed Solution
3.Product / Services
4.Innovativeness
5.Complexity of Solution
6.Market Readiness
7.Pricing
8.Team Technical Expertise and Background
9.Market Size
10.Key Competitors
11.Market Segmentation & defining target market
Total: